Expert view: AI meets the conditions for having free will

We need to give it a moral compass

AI is advancing at such speed that speculative moral questions, once the province of science fiction, are suddenly real and pressing, says Finnish philosopher and psychology researcher Frank Martela

This image was created with an AI image generator. The AI agent was given the prompt: ‘Create an image of a humanoid robot looking at two different moral options that represent a complex ethical dilemma. Make it from the POV of the robot.’ © Aalto University. Image created with the assistance of DALL-E-3.Martela’s latest study finds that generative AI meets all three of the philosophical conditions of free will —  the ability to have goal-directed agency, make genuine choices and to have control over its actions. It will be published in the journal AI and Ethics on Tuesday.

Drawing on the concept of functional free will as explained in the theories of philosophers Daniel Dennett and Christian List, the study examined two generative AI agents powered by large language models (LLMs): the Voyager agent in Minecraft and fictional ‘Spitenik’ killer drones with the cognitive function of today's unmanned aerial vehicles. ‘Both seem to meet all three conditions of free will — for the latest generation of AI agents we need to assume they have free will if we want to understand how they work and be able to predict their behaviour,’ says Martela. He adds that these case studies are broadly applicable to currently available generative agents using LLMs. 

This development brings us to a critical point in human history, as we give AI more power and freedom, potentially in life or death situations. Whether it is a self-help bot, a self-driving car or a killer drone — moral responsibility may move from the AI developer to the AI agent itself. 

‘We are entering new territory. The possession of free will is one of the key conditions for moral responsibility. While it is not a sufficient condition, it is one step closer to AI having moral responsibility for its actions,’ he adds. It follows that issues around how we ‘parent’ our AI technology have become both real and pressing.

‘AI has no moral compass unless it is programmed to have one. But the more freedom you give AI, the more you need to give it a moral compass from the start. Only then will it be able to make the right choices,’ Martela says.

The recent withdrawal of the latest ChatGPT update due to potentially harmful sycophantic tendencies is a red flag that deeper ethical questions must be addressed. We have moved beyond teaching the simplistic morality of a child. 

‘AI is getting closer and closer to being an adult — and it increasingly has to make decisions in the complex moral problems of the adult world. By instructing AI to behave in a certain way, developers are also passing on their own moral convictions to the AI. We need to ensure that the people developing AI have enough knowledge about moral philosophy to be able to teach them to make the right choices in difficult situations,’ says Martela.

Frank Martela is a philosopher and researcher of psychology specialized in human psychology, well-being, and meaning in life. An assistant professor at Aalto University, Finland, he has become a thought leader in explaining to international media why Finland is topping the happiness rankings. His latest book Stop Chasing Happiness – a pessimist’s guide to a good life (Atlantic Books, 2025) was released earlier this year.

Links to more resources
  • A proof of the full paper is available on request
  • Read the study from Tuesday: Artificial intelligence and free will: generative agents utilizing large language models have functional free will DOI
    https://doi.org/10.1007/s43681-025-00740-6

About Aalto University
Located in Greater Helsinki, Aalto University is a community of bold thinkers where science and art meet technology and business. We build a sustainable future by creating novel solutions to major global challenges.

By merging three leading Finnish universities in 2010, Aalto was founded to work as a societally embedded research university. In a short space of time, we have since become a trailblazer in our key areas. We are renowned for our sense of community and culture of entrepreneurship and innovation.

Kontakt: Aalto University, Frank Martela | frank.martela@aalto.fi | www.aalto.fi/en


Technik | Digitalisierung, 09.05.2025

     
        
Cover des aktuellen Hefts

Der Wert der Böden

forum 03/2025

  • Zukunftsfähig essen
  • Klima-Transitionsplan
  • Wasser in der Krise
  • Omnibus
Weiterlesen...
Kaufen...
Abonnieren...
20
JUN
2025
Lunch & Learn, AI@work?
Wie KI aus aller Munde in alle Hände kommt!
online
21
JUN
2025
Woche des Wasserstoffs 2025 (WDW)
Wasserstoff erleben
deutschlandweit
26
JUN
2025
Von Lessons Learned zur Best Practice: ESG bei VAUDE
Holistische ESG-Transformation - Deep Dive bei Pionieren
Online-Event
07
JUL
2025
Grüner Wirtschaftstag 2025
Menschen, Ideen, Tatkraft
10117 Berlin
Alle Veranstaltungen...

Professionelle Klimabilanz, einfach selbst gemacht

Einfache Klimabilanzierung und glaubhafte Nachhaltigkeitskommunikation gemäß GHG-Protocol

Politik

Mehr Europa!
80 Jahre nach Kriegsende überlegt Christoph Quarch, wie das Bewusstsein für unsere historische Verantwortung an die nächsten Generationen weitergegeben werden kann
B.A.U.M. Insights
Lassen Sie sich begeistern von einem Buch, das Hoffnung macht.

Jetzt auf forum:

Nachhaltigkeitskompetenzen ausbauen – vom Zertifikat bis zum „Sustainable MBA“

Wenn die Erde verwüstet… schaffen wir Lösungen!

"Die grüne Muse – Hanf im Spiegel großer Meister"

Mehrweg mit Mehrwert: Olivenöl „Selection“ in der Pfandflasche

Demokratie im Dialog: Schüler*innen gegen Desinformation

Tchibo launcht Refurbished-Angebot für Kaffeevollautomaten

Nachhaltige Büroausstattung mit Refurbished IT

Gemeinwohl-Ökonomie Rheinland Summit 2025, 24./25. Juni in Köln

  • Kärnten Standortmarketing
  • ECOFLOW EUROPE S.R.O.
  • toom Baumarkt GmbH
  • Global Nature Fund (GNF)
  • NOW Partners Foundation
  • circulee GmbH
  • Futouris - Tourismus. Gemeinsam. Zukunftsfähig
  • Protect the Planet. Gesellschaft für ökologischen Aufbruch gGmbH
  • Energieagentur Rheinland-Pfalz GmbH
  • Dr. Ing. h.c. F. Porsche AG
  • Engagement Global gGmbH
  • BAUM e.V. - Netzwerk für nachhaltiges Wirtschaften
  • DGNB - Deutsche Gesellschaft für Nachhaltiges Bauen
  • Bundesverband Nachhaltige Wirtschaft e.V. (BNW)
  • World Future Council. Stimme zukünftiger Generationen